Tuesday, January 11, 2005

consent, difficult concept

the trial of abu ghraib prison guard charles graner began yesterday. graner's lawyer, guy womack said in his opening statements that using naked and hooded detainees to make a human pyramid was much like what cheerleaders "all over America" do at football games.

what an argument! maybe in his next few cases, womack will use the following:

-when defending a person accused of embezzling for transferring his company's pension fund into his personal checking account, womack could say: "All my client did is transfer funds from one account to another. Balance transfers happen every day all over America, our economy could not exist without them."

-when defending a person accused of rape, womack could say: "The prosecution says my client had sexual intercourse. But people have sexual intercourse every day, our species' survival depends upon it."

-when defending a person accused of stabbing someone in the heart: "What my client is accused of doing is no different from what surgeons do all the time all across america. They're even paid a tidy sum for their efforts. The question here is not whether my client is guilty of any crime, but rather why he never received any pay for it."